.png)
Find your perfect neighborhood
Use our interactive map search tool
Get an INSTANT, accurate home valuation
Stay up to date on the local real estate market
In the heart of Ohio, New Carlisle's real estate market is as diverse as its community. From charming, affordable starter homes perfect for first-time buyers, to sprawling farms and exquisite estates on the outskirts of town, there's a piece of New Carlisle to call your own. Whether you're looking to buy your first home, seeking a larger space for your growing family, or searching for the peace and tranquility of rural living, New Carlisle has something to offer.
When navigating the New Carlisle real estate market, it's crucial to have knowledgeable and experienced professionals by your side. Realtors Don & Cyndi Shurts of Keller Williams Advisors Realty are your local experts, dedicated to helping you find the perfect home or sell your property in New Carlisle. With their deep understanding of the local market trends, vast network, and commitment to personalized service, Don & Cyndi Shurts are equipped to guide you through every step of the buying or selling process.
Community and Recreation: New Carlisle is not just about homes; it's about community. Enjoy family-friendly activities at Smith Park, engage in sports, or spend your weekends exploring the Sugar Isle golf course.
Local Attractions: Meadow View Growers is more than a garden center; it's a local treasure that draws visitors from across the region with its beautiful selection of plants and engaging activities.
Diverse Real Estate Options: With a wide range of housing options, you're sure to find a property that suits your style, needs, and budget.
Adding to the charm of New Carlisle is the beloved Mel-o-dee Restaurant, a local favorite that has been serving the community with delicious, home-style meals for years. It's a perfect spot for gathering with friends and family, showcasing the warmth and welcoming nature of New Carlisle's residents.
For those seeking spiritual community or a place to worship, New Carlisle is home to numerous houses of worship, including the Medway Church. These institutions play a vital role in the community, offering spiritual guidance and a sense of belonging to residents and newcomers alike.
If you're considering buying or selling a home in New Carlisle, Ohio, let Don & Cyndi Shurts be your trusted partners. With their expertise and passion for the community, they'll help you navigate the New Carlisle real estate market with confidence. For personalized service and expert advice, contact Don at 937-241-2124 or Cyndi at 937-604-5194.
Embark on your New Carlisle adventure today. Explore homes for sale, discover the community, and find your place in this historic, vibrant town. Whether you're buying your first home or selling your property, New Carlisle welcomes you to be part of its future, as it continues to grow and thrive while honoring its past.
Welcome to 1101 North Scott Street in New Carlisle, a move-in ready home providing comfort, convenience, and plenty of outdoor space to enjoy. Situated on a generously si...
Courtesy of Steven Koleno and Beycome Brokerage Realty LLC
Welcome home to this beautifully updated 3-bedroom, 1-bath ranch offering 1,250 square feet of move-in-ready living space. A spacious 11’ x 24’ bonus room provides endles...
Courtesy of Diana Taylor and BHHS Professional Realty
Discover the charm of suburban living at this delightful ranch-style home, perfectly situated in Bethel Twp, Ohio. A well-maintained property awaits, offering a comfortab...
Courtesy of Joni Schumann and Irongate Inc.
Welcome home to this beautifully maintained 3-bedroom, 2-bath residence offering 1,635 square feet of comfortable, modern living space. The open-concept floor plan featur...
Courtesy of Karen Mcrill and Plum Tree Realty
Discover the Aldridge, a charming ranch-style residence nestled in the serene Reserve of Honey Creek in New Carlisle, offering an unparalleled living experience. This bra...
Courtesy of James McKinney and D.R. Horton Realty of Ohio Inc
Discover the charm of single-story living in this delightful ranch home featuring 2 bedrooms with a possible smaller third bedroom or an office, perfectly situated in New...
Courtesy of Jeff Horne and Coldwell Banker Heritage
Find yourself at home at the Reserves of Honey Creek a community by D.R. Horton in New Carlisle! . The Henley is a thoughtfully designed two-story home that blends comfor...
Courtesy of James McKinney and D.R. Horton Realty of Ohio Inc
Discover unparalleled comfort and modern living in the Taylor floorplan, a captivating two-story residence nestled within the vibrant Honey Creek Community. This exquisit...
Courtesy of James McKinney and D.R. Horton Realty of Ohio Inc
Discover unparalleled comfort and contemporary elegance in this exquisite Holcombe floor plan, nestled within the scenic Reserves of Honey Creek in New Carlisle, a vibran...
Courtesy of James McKinney and D.R. Horton Realty of Ohio Inc
Discover unparalleled comfort and contemporary elegance in this exquisite Holcombe floor plan, nestled within the scenic Reserves of Honey Creek in New Carlisle, a vibran...
Courtesy of James McKinney and D.R. Horton Realty of Ohio Inc
Discover unparalleled comfort and modern living in the Taylor floorplan, a captivating two-story residence nestled within the vibrant Honey Creek Community. This exquisit...
Courtesy of James McKinney and D.R. Horton Realty of Ohio Inc
Discover the charm of this well-maintained ranch in New Carlisle, offering an exceptional blend of indoor and outdoor spaces for relaxation and entertaining. This home fe...
Courtesy of Joyce A Lightner and Garden Gate Realty Inc.
Discover the tranquility of New Carlisle living in this charming single-family residence, offering a seamless blend of comfort and convenience. This delightful home prese...
Courtesy of Deborah K Sowder and RE/MAX Victory + Affiliates
This beautiful 2,343 sq ft Spruce model offers, 4 bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms provide all the comfort, style, and functionality today's buyers are searching for. You'll know ...
Courtesy of Ryan Del Monte and Keller Williams Seven Hills
Discover the charm of 304 Sunset Drive, a delightful single-family residence nestled in New Carlisle, OH, offering a serene lifestyle. This inviting home boasts three bed...
Courtesy of Steve Callahan and Plum Tree Realty
This spacious two-story home offers 4 bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms with plenty of room for comfortable living and entertaining. The inviting layout features generous liv...
Courtesy of Tonya Snyder and RE/MAX Alliance Realty
Completely renovated and move-in ready, this 3-bedroom, 2-bath home offers stylish updates throughout, including new flooring, updated lighting, brand new kitchen cabinet...
Courtesy of Donna J Cook and Bruns Realty Group, LLC
Wide-Open Acreage with Maximum Usability in Bucolic Country Setting Lot 6 features 10.4 acres of fully usable, gently rolling terrain—no HOA. With highly flexible open sp...
Courtesy of Steven P Clark and J.M. Williams Realty, LLC
From Your Rural Dreams, a Breathtaking, Expansive Parcel with Dual Road Access The largest offering at 12.6 acres, Lot 7 accessibility shall be from Tipp Elizabeth — no ...
Courtesy of Steven P Clark and J.M. Williams Realty, LLC
Tree-Lined Privacy with Flexible Layout in Rural Paradise A well-balanced 10.4-acre parcel featuring established tree lines that provide natural screening and definition—...
Courtesy of Steven P Clark and J.M. Williams Realty, LLC
An Open Homesite in Bucolic Setting with Exceptional Flexibility Lot 2 offers 10.4 acres of gently rolling, open land in the heart of Elizabeth Township with no HOA. With...
Courtesy of Steven P Clark and J.M. Williams Realty, LLC
Expansive Lot with Clean Layout, Multiple Building Options in Pastoral Setting A well-proportioned 10.4-acre parcel offering open, gently rolling terrain and multiple ide...
Courtesy of Steven P Clark and J.M. Williams Realty, LLC
Peaceful, Scenic, Rural Setting with Natural Privacy This 10.4-acre homesite offers gently rolling land with mature trees that create natural privacy and visual interest—...
Courtesy of Steven P Clark and J.M. Williams Realty, LLC
A Private, Secluded Homesite with Natural Beauty A rare opportunity to own a 10.4-acre homesite in highly desirable Elizabeth Township—no HOA. Positioned at the end of th...
Courtesy of Steven P Clark and J.M. Williams Realty, LLC
Nestled in a vibrant community, this property at 312 W Jefferson St is ideally positioned to enjoy local amenities and the charm of New Carlisle. The strategic location p...
Courtesy of Julie Hay and Howard Hanna Real Estate Serv
The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Broker Reciprocity program of the Dayton Area Board of Realtors® MLS IDX Database. Real estate listings from the Dayton Area Board of Realtors® MLS IDX Database held by brokerage firms other than KELLER WILLIAMS COMMUNITY PARTNERS are marked with the IDX logo and are provided by the Dayton Area Board of Realtors® MLS IDX Database. Information is provided for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in. Copyright© 2026 Dayton Area Board of Realtors®
