.png)
Find your perfect neighborhood
Use our interactive map search tool
Get an INSTANT, accurate home valuation
Stay up to date on the local real estate market
In the heart of Ohio, New Carlisle's real estate market is as diverse as its community. From charming, affordable starter homes perfect for first-time buyers, to sprawling farms and exquisite estates on the outskirts of town, there's a piece of New Carlisle to call your own. Whether you're looking to buy your first home, seeking a larger space for your growing family, or searching for the peace and tranquility of rural living, New Carlisle has something to offer.
When navigating the New Carlisle real estate market, it's crucial to have knowledgeable and experienced professionals by your side. Realtors Don & Cyndi Shurts of Keller Williams Advisors Realty are your local experts, dedicated to helping you find the perfect home or sell your property in New Carlisle. With their deep understanding of the local market trends, vast network, and commitment to personalized service, Don & Cyndi Shurts are equipped to guide you through every step of the buying or selling process.
Community and Recreation: New Carlisle is not just about homes; it's about community. Enjoy family-friendly activities at Smith Park, engage in sports, or spend your weekends exploring the Sugar Isle golf course.
Local Attractions: Meadow View Growers is more than a garden center; it's a local treasure that draws visitors from across the region with its beautiful selection of plants and engaging activities.
Diverse Real Estate Options: With a wide range of housing options, you're sure to find a property that suits your style, needs, and budget.
Adding to the charm of New Carlisle is the beloved Mel-o-dee Restaurant, a local favorite that has been serving the community with delicious, home-style meals for years. It's a perfect spot for gathering with friends and family, showcasing the warmth and welcoming nature of New Carlisle's residents.
For those seeking spiritual community or a place to worship, New Carlisle is home to numerous houses of worship, including the Medway Church. These institutions play a vital role in the community, offering spiritual guidance and a sense of belonging to residents and newcomers alike.
If you're considering buying or selling a home in New Carlisle, Ohio, let Don & Cyndi Shurts be your trusted partners. With their expertise and passion for the community, they'll help you navigate the New Carlisle real estate market with confidence. For personalized service and expert advice, contact Don at 937-241-2124 or Cyndi at 937-604-5194.
Embark on your New Carlisle adventure today. Explore homes for sale, discover the community, and find your place in this historic, vibrant town. Whether you're buying your first home or selling your property, New Carlisle welcomes you to be part of its future, as it continues to grow and thrive while honoring its past.
Nestled along the outskirts of New Carlisle, this early-1900s Cape Cod is full of character and lovingly maintained by the same owners for over 40 years. Updates include ...
Courtesy of Ronald L Grout and BHHS Professional Realty
None
Courtesy of Ronald L Grout and BHHS Professional Realty
Character, space & a setting unlike anything else! This charming historic home offers 2,320sqft with 3 bedrooms, 2 full baths & sits on 2.32 beautiful acres. Once owned b...
Courtesy of Olivia Nicodemus and Streetlight Realty LLC
Welcome to Silverlake Estates! This updated 3 bedroom, 1 bath ranch offers approximately 1,250 sq ft of comfortable living space in one of New Carlisle’s established neig...
Courtesy of Mike Kelly and Sibcy Cline Inc.
This move-in ready property offers plenty of space and comfort, with features designed for both everyday living and entertaining. The spacious family room is the perfect ...
Courtesy of Emilee Morris and BHHS Professional Realty
This home has recently been updated Siding ,Roof ,Kitchen ,windows interior doors and trim to name a few. Walk in shower. Larger ranch then most in the area with 1.1 Ba...
Courtesy of Joy Haynes and Howard Hanna Real Estate Serv
WELCOME TO ARBOR HOMES! This thoughtfully designed home offers the ease of single-story living with modern finishes and practical features throughout. Featuring 9-foot f...
Courtesy of Ryan Del Monte and Keller Williams Seven Hills
WELCOME TO ARBOR HOMES! The Bradford is a thoughtfully designed single-story home offering comfortable, efficient living with modern finishes throughout. The exterior fe...
Courtesy of Ryan Del Monte and Keller Williams Seven Hills
If you are looking for a cute ranch in a nice neighborhood then you have found it! This 3 bed/2 bath brick ranch has been in the family for decades and has been well mai...
Courtesy of Richard Herbst and Keller Williams Home Town Rlty
Welcome to 223 Prentice Drive, a refreshed single-story home offering 2 bedrooms, 1 full bathroom, and 1,075 square feet of flexible living space. LVP flooring flows thro...
Courtesy of Arthur Solomon and Coldwell Banker Heritage
Welcome to this spacious and inviting 3-bedroom, 3-full-bath home offering over 3,200 square feet of living space, perfectly situated on an impressive 1.69-acre lot. From...
Courtesy of Matthew Witt and Howard Hanna Real Estate Serv
Welcome to peaceful country living with room to live, work, and grow! This charming 3-bedroom, 2 full bathroom ranch is situated on 2.78 picturesque acres surrounded by b...
Courtesy of Ana Krohn and eXp Realty
1 story Ranch vinyl home in New Carlile with large livign room and 3 bedrooms, 840 sqft. with 2 car detached garage. Wood deck off the back of the house, opens to a open ...
Courtesy of Elizabeth L Shockey and Local Roots Realty
Welcome home to this move-in ready, 3 Bedroom/1 Bath plus a dedicated office turnkey ranch in the heart of New Carlisle! Beautifully updated. This charming home features ...
Courtesy of Nicholas Huscroft and Chosen Real Estate Group
Quality-built by Arcon Builders, this custom home is filled with thoughtful upgrades and timeless details. The open foyer welcomes you into a spacious interior featuring ...
Courtesy of Scot M Rife and Plum Tree Realty
Discover the charm and potential of country living on this beautiful 5.5-acre mini farm! This well-maintained 2-bedroom, 1-bath home features newer siding and a newer roo...
Courtesy of Gail Derr and Irongate, Inc.
Looking for acreage with investment & development potential then you have found it. 74.97 rolling acres in popular Elizabeth Township / Miami East LSD with 2917 feet of ...
Courtesy of Steven P Clark and J.M. Williams Realty, LLC
Exceptional equestrian property offering outstanding facilities for the horse enthusiast plus excellent potential for boarding, training and lessons. Thoughtfully designe...
Courtesy of Cynthia L Shurts and Keller Williams Community Part
Welcome to 377 Bischoff Road, a charming 4-bedroom, 1-bath farmhouse nestled on approximately one acre in New Carlisle. Offering no HOA and no rear neighbors, the propert...
Courtesy of Amanda Wilson and eXp Realty
Welcome to this stunning modern brick home with 4 bedrooms, 4.5 bathrooms, full finished basement, 3 car-attached garage all sitting on a 0.776-acre lot, looking over the...
Courtesy of Charlene Roberge and Lagonda Creek Real Estate LLC
Welcome home to this beautifully situated 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath home offering 2,635 sq. ft. of comfortable living space on a picturesque 5-acre lot. From the moment you arr...
Courtesy of Marc Broomhall and Howard Hanna Real Estate Serv
This beautiful brick ranch 3 bedroom 2 bath home with unfinished basement is offering 1,440 square feet of living space and is move in ready. Large laundry room and mud ...
Courtesy of Sonja M Jenkins and Howard Hanna Real Estate Serv
Enjoy peaceful views of open fields from this spacious 2002 Dutch Heritage modular home located in Brookwood Mobile Home Park, a 55+ community. Offering over 1,600 square...
Courtesy of Arthur Solomon and Coldwell Banker Heritage
EExtra Large Open Floorplan Ranch in Park Layne Manor 3 bedrooms 1 bath, Huge Living Room, Dining Room plus Breakfast area. Updated Kitchen & Bath. SS Gas Range, Dishwash...
Courtesy of Jeff Horne and Coldwell Banker Heritage
Welcome to 703 W Washington St in New Carlisle! This spacious 3 bedroom, 2 bath brick ranch offers nearly 1,600 sq. ft. of comfortable single level living in the Terra Vi...
Courtesy of James Gray and Glasshouse Realty Group
The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Broker Reciprocity program of the Dayton Area Board of Realtors® MLS IDX Database. Real estate listings from the Dayton Area Board of Realtors® MLS IDX Database held by brokerage firms other than KELLER WILLIAMS COMMUNITY PARTNERS are marked with the IDX logo and are provided by the Dayton Area Board of Realtors® MLS IDX Database. Information is provided for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in. Copyright© 2026 Dayton Area Board of Realtors®
